Feb 19, 2025

Overpriced Home: What Every Seller Should Know

📺 Watch the Video: YouTube Link Here

Overpriced Homes: What Every Seller Needs to Know

Pricing Your Home Right: The Key to a Successful Sale

When selling your home, pricing is everything. Many sellers start with a number in mind based on what their neighbors are asking. But here’s the truth—the market decides the value, not the seller.

It’s tempting to price high and “leave room for negotiation,” but that strategy often backfires. If a home sits too long on the market, buyers start to wonder: “What’s wrong with it?” The longer it lingers, the harder it is to sell at a good price.

So, how do you avoid this mistake? By understanding what determines market value.

What Determines Your Home’s Market Value?

Several key factors influence how much buyers are willing to pay:

✔️ Recent home sales in your neighborhood (not just listing prices!)
✔️ Current market conditions—are homes selling fast or sitting for months?
✔️ Your home’s condition compared to similar properties
✔️ Any upgrades or renovations that add value
✔️ The competition—other homes on the market at similar price points

Understanding these factors helps position your home at the right price—one that attracts serious buyers and maximizes your final sale price.

The Risks of Overpricing

Overpricing your home leads to two common problems:

1. Few or No Showings

If your price is too high, buyers will scroll right past your listing. Today’s buyers do their homework, and if your price is unrealistic, they won’t waste their time.

2. Showings with No Offers

If you’re slightly overpriced, you may get showings—but no one will bite. Buyers compare value across listings, and if yours seems overpriced, they’ll choose a better deal elsewhere.

Why Buyers Ignore Overpriced Homes

Here’s something surprising: Buyers often won’t make a low offer on an overpriced home.

Why? They don’t want to insult the seller. Instead of negotiating, they’ll move on to another home that’s priced right.

And the longer your home sits unsold, the more skeptical buyers become. They start thinking:

  • “Maybe there’s something wrong with it.”
  • “If no one else is interested, should I be worried?”
  • “I’ll wait for the price to drop.”

This can force you into bigger price reductions than if you had priced correctly from the start.

How to Set the Right Price for Your Home

The best way to get the most money for your home is to price it competitively from day one. Here’s how:

Start with a Professional Market Analysis

Base your price on real data—not wishful thinking. Look at recent sales, not just asking prices.

Be Objective About Your Home’s Condition

Your home might be beautiful, but buyers compare it to others in the same price range. Make sure the price reflects reality.

Watch Market Trends

Markets shift. If homes are selling quickly, you may have room to push the price higher. If sales are slowing down, a competitive price is key.

Adjust If Needed

If your home isn’t getting offers, listen to the market. It might be time for a small adjustment to attract buyers.

📍 Related: Canada has the Most Overvalued Housing Market in World

Overpricing Can Cost You More in the Long Run

A common myth is that starting high and lowering the price later is a smart strategy. But in reality:

🚨 Homes that sit on the market for too long sell for LESS.
🚨 Buyers use long market times as a negotiation tool.
🚨 Each price reduction signals desperation to buyers.

The best way to maximize your profit is to price your home right from the start.


🏡 Thinking About Selling? Let’s Get It Right!

At Peter Thompson Real Estate, we help homeowners in Quebec sell fast and for top dollar with smart pricing strategies and expert market insights.

💬 Want to know your home’s true value? Let’s chat! Contact us today.

📞 Call Peter Thompson: (438) 500-8344
📩 Email: peter@peterthompson.ca

🔗 More Resources:


This is #AskPete. If you have any real estate questions, feel free to send them and I will get you the answers. Or stay up to date on the latest tips for real estate buyers and sellers by clicking the YouTube button below:

Latest posts

Are you looking to buy or sell a property? Get in touch today